The Fisherman — John Langan (2016) · Novel · winner · Source
Haven — Tom Deady (2016) · First Novel · winner · Source
Snowed — Maria Alexander (2016) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
Kolchak the Night Stalker: The Forgotten Lore of Edgar Allan Poe — James Chambers (2016) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
The Doll-Master and Other Tales of Terror — Joyce Carol Oates (2016) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
Borderlands 6 — Thomas F. Monteleone and Olivia F. Monteleone (2016) · Anthology · winner · Source
Shirley Jackson: A Rather Haunted Life — Ruth Franklin (2016) · Non-Fiction · winner · Source
Brothel — Stephanie M. Wytovich (2016) · Poetry Collection · winner · Source
Ararat — Christopher Golden (2017) · Novel · winner · Source
Cold Cuts — Robert Payne Cabeen (2017) · First Novel · winner · Source
The Last Harvest — Kim Liggett (2017) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
Kindred: A Graphic Novel Adaptation — Damian Duffy and Octavia E. Butler (2017) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
Strange Weather — Joe Hill (2017) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
Behold!: Oddities, Curiosities & Undefinable Wonders — Doug Murano (2017) · Anthology · winner · Source
Paperbacks from Hell: The Twisted History of ‘70s and ‘80s Horror Fiction — Grady Hendrix (2017) · Non-Fiction · winner · Source
A Collection of Nightmares — Christina Sng (2017) · Poetry Collection · winner · Source
The Cabin at the End of the World — Paul Tremblay (2018) · Novel · winner · Source
The Rust Maidens — Gwendolyn Kiste (2018) · First Novel · winner · Source
The Dark Descent of Elizabeth Frankenstein — Kiersten White (2018) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
Victor LaValle’s Destroyer — Victor LaValle (2018) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
That Which Grows Wild — Eric J. Guignard (2018) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
The Devil and the Deep: Horror Stories of the Sea — Ellen Datlow (2018) · Anthology · winner · Source
It’s Alive: Bringing Your Nightmares to Life — Joe Mynhardt and Eugene Johnson (2018) · Non-Fiction · winner · Source
The Devil’s Dreamland — Sara Tantlinger (2018) · Poetry Collection · winner · Source
Coyote Rage — Owl Goingback (2019) · Novel · winner · Source
The Bone Weaver’s Orchard — Sarah Read (2019) · First Novel · winner · Source
Oware Mosaic — Nzondi (2019) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
Neil Gaiman’s Snow, Glass, Apples — Colleen Doran and Neil Gaiman (2019) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
Growing Things and Other Stories — Paul Tremblay (2019) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
Echoes: The Saga Anthology of Ghost Stories — Ellen Datlow (2019) · Anthology · winner · Source
Monster, She Wrote: The Women Who Pioneered Horror and Speculative Fiction — Lisa Kröger and Melanie R. Anderson (2019) · Non-Fiction · winner · Source
The Place of Broken Things — Linda D. Addison and Alessandro Manzetti (2019) · Poetry Collection · winner · Source
The Only Good Indians — Stephen Graham Jones (2020) · Novel · winner · Source
The Fourth Whore — EV Knight (2020) · First Novel · winner · Source
Mary Shelley Presents — Nancy Holder (2020) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
Clown in a Cornfield — Adam Cesare (2020) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
Grotesque: Monster Stories — Lee Murray (2020) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
A Collection of Dreamscapes — Christina Sng (2020) · Poetry Collection · winner · Source
Black Cranes: Tales of Unquiet Women — Lee Murray and Geneve Flynn (2020) · Anthology · winner · Source
Writing in the Dark — Tim Waggoner (2020) · Non-Fiction · winner · Source
My Heart is a Chainsaw — Stephen Graham Jones (2021) · Novel · winner · Source
Queen of Teeth — Hailey Piper (2021) · First Novel · winner · Source
The River Has Teeth — Erica Waters (2021) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
The Inhabitant of the Lake — Alessandro Manzetti and Stefano Cardoselli (2021) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
In That Endlessness, Our End — Gemma Files (2021) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
When Things Get Dark: Stories Inspired by Shirley Jackson — Ellen Datlow (2021) · Anthology · winner · Source
Writers Workshop of Horror 2 — Michael Knost (2021) · Non-Fiction · winner · Source
Tortured Willows: Bent. Bowed. Unbroken. — Christina Sng and Angela Yuriko Smith and Lee Murray and Geneve Flynn (2021) · Poetry Collection · winner · Source
The Devil Takes You Home — Gabino Iglesias (2022) · Novel · winner · Source
Beulah — Christi Nogle (2022) · First Novel · winner · Source
They Stole Our Hearts — Daniel Kraus (2022) · Middle Grade Novel · winner · Source
Kolchak: The Night Stalker: 50th Anniversary — James Aquilone (2022) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
The Triangle — Robert P. Ottone (2022) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
Breakable Things — Cassandra Khaw (2022) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
Crime Scene — Cynthia Pelayo (2022) · Poetry Collection · winner · Source
Screams from the Dark: 29 Tales of Monsters and the Monstrous — Ellen Datlow (2022) · Anthology · winner · Source
Writing in the Dark: The Workbook — Tim Waggoner (2022) · Non-Fiction · winner · Source
Out There Screaming — Jordan Peele and John Joseph Adams (2023) · Anthology · winner · Source
Blood from the Air — Gemma Files (2023) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
The Daughters of Block Island — Christa Carmen (2023) · First Novel · winner · Source
Carmilla: The First Vampire — Amy Chu (2023) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
101 Horror Books to Read Before You’re Murdered — Sadie Hartmann (2023) · Long Nonfiction · winner · Source
The Nighthouse Keeper — Lora Senf (2023) · Middle Grade Novel · winner · Source
The Reformatory — Tananarive Due (2023) · Novel · winner · Source
On the Subject of Blackberries — Stephanie M. Wytovich (2023) · Poetry · winner · Source
She Is a Haunting — Trang Thanh Tran (2023) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
The Haunting of Velkwood — Gwendolyn Kiste (2024) · Novel · winner · Source
The Eyes Are the Best Part — Monika Kim (2024) · First Novel · winner · Source
There’s Something Sinister in Center Field — Robert P. Ottone (2024) · Middle Grade Novel · winner · Source
The Creepening of Dogwood House — Eden Royce (2024) · Middle Grade Novel · winner · Source
Clown in a Cornfield 3: The Church of Frendo — Adam Cesare (2024) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source
Love is a Crematorium and Other Tales — Mercedes M. Yardley (2024) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
Discontinue If Death Ensues: Tales from the Tipping Point — Carol Gyzander & Anna Taborska (2024) · Anthology · winner · Source
Horror for Weenies: Everything You Need to Know About the Films You’re Too Scared to Watch — Emily C. Hughes (2024) · Long Non-Fiction · winner · Source
Mexicans on the Moon: Speculative Poetry from a Possible Future — Pedro Iniguez (2024) · Poetry · winner · Source
H. P. Lovecraft’s The Call of Cthulhu — Gou Tanabe (2024) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
Silk & Sinew: A Collection of Folk Horror from the Asian Diaspora — Kristy Park Kulski (2025) · Anthology · winner · Source
Lost in The Dark and Other Excursions — John Langan (2025) · Fiction Collection · winner · Source
The October Film Haunt — Michael Wehunt (2025) · First Novel · winner · Source
Bowling with Corpses and Other Strange Tales from Lands Unknown — Mike Mignola (2025) · Graphic Novel · winner · Source
Why I Love Horror: Essays on Horror Literature — Becky Siegel Spratford (2025) · Long Non-Fiction · winner · Source
Ride or Die — Delilah S. Dawson (2025) · Middle Grade Novel · winner · Source
The Buffalo Hunter Hunter — Stephen Graham Jones (2025) · Novel · winner · Source
Everything Endless — Linda D. Addison and Jamal Hodge (2025) · Poetry · winner · Source
Shiny Happy People — Clay McLeod Chapman (2025) · Young Adult Novel · winner · Source